top of page
Writer's pictureNate "Jetski" Jeschke

The Problem With Militias

Updated: Apr 23

The Founders' Vision: An Individual Right to Bear Arms

When the 2nd Amendment was enshrined in the Bill of Rights, the United States had no standing national army. Instead, the "militia" referred to all able-bodied male citizens who could be called upon to take up arms in service of their state or the young nation. This militia was intended to be the whole people trained in the use of firearms.

From this historical context, a compelling argument emerges: the 2nd Amendment established an individual right to keep and bear arms, rather than a collective right limited only to organized militia groups. The prefatory clause referring to a "well regulated Militia" served to announce a civic rationale – that the people at large must be armed to secure a free state.

This "originalist" interpretation suggests the framers did not intend to restrict gun ownership solely to those actively serving in militias. Instead, the right extended to all able-bodied men, who were considered the unorganized militia pool itself. Many historians and legal scholars contend this aligns with the Amendment's meaning and the founders' intent.



Maintaining an Armed and Trained Populace

The founders envisioned the militia being comprised of armed citizens who were already proficient with firearms through individual ownership and training. The militia itself was not intended to train and arm the populace. Rather, it relied on able-bodied men independently maintaining their readiness by keeping and practicing with their own arms. This existing armed citizenry could then be rapidly integrated into an organized "well-regulated militia" force when required for security purposes. The responsibility fell on individuals to first exercise their right to bear arms privately, which in turn enabled the formation of an effective militia when needed.



 Personal Responsibility Underpinning the Militia Concept

The core issue with how many approach militias today is looking to these groups as the primary means of obtaining skills, gear, and paramilitary training they currently lack. However, this contradicts the foundational principle of personal responsibility behind the well-regulated militia concept. Rather than joining a militia to receive that instruction, individuals should first dedicate themselves to developing the necessary capabilities through self-motivated training and study. This includes pursuing physical fitness, weapons proficiency, medical readiness, and other relevant competencies independently. While group settings like classes can facilitate this development, the onus remains on each able-bodied person to put in the hard work of becoming truly prepared. The militia was intended as a temporary assembly of already capable citizens unified for a common defensive need - not as a shortcut around the self-reliance required to first attain that baseline readiness. Merely affiliating with a militia in hopes it will provide gear and experience inverts the self-driven commitment expected of prospective members.



Legitimate Militias Require Personal Preparedness and Genuine Need

Militias are not inherently evil, but should only be formed for a legitimate need requiring an organized armed force. The founders envisioned militias as temporary assemblies of already prepared citizens unified to secure the free state. For a militia to truly be "well-regulated," it must consist of individuals who have taken personal responsibility to first become trained and capable through self-driven efforts. Prematurely establishing a militia without this foundational preparedness risks creating an ill-equipped paramilitary group lacking purpose. While the right to bear arms is protected, the serious act of forming a militia should be reserved for genuine existential threats requiring civilian defense. Through personal dedication first, any future undertaking of a well-regulated militia becomes valid rather than merely reactionary.

18 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page